Usually the kind of story that has the OOC weepiness that I like is an h/c story with both physical and emotional trauma. Often there's an element of misunderstanding or suspense. The character ususally feels isolated or alone and the story is one of coming to belong to someone(s). And frequently, the story is about a solid C or B- in terms of writing

Ahahaha I think the story I linked you to below might fit that bill, if you haven't read it before. John/Rodney kidfic, prompting John to deal with his long-repressed gayness.